Planning and strategy
Scale, watch or cut: how to decide what to do with each campaign
Every campaign deserves one clear decision each month. Here's a simple rule, based on what your jobs earn, that tells you when to add budget, when to hold and when to stop.
Judge each campaign on closed revenue from your CRM against the margin of the jobs it brings. Scale when it beats target for two months and the crew has room. Watch when it's between break-even and target. Cut when it stays below break-even with enough data, after trying to fix what sits behind it.
Most campaigns live on autopilot: the same budget, month after month, whether they’re working or not. Somebody set them up two years ago and nobody wants to touch them. A clear monthly decision for each one changes that, and it’s simpler than it sounds.
Set the bar from your margins
A campaign pays only if its revenue covers what the jobs cost to deliver.
Break-even ROAS = 1 ÷ gross margin
Target ROAS ≈ 1.5 × break-even
A replacement campaign at a 40% margin breaks even at 2.5 times and targets about 3.8 times. A repair campaign at 55% breaks even at about 1.8 times and targets about 2.7 times.
The three decisions
| Decision | When | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Scale | At or above target for two months, levers healthy, crew has room | Budget up about 20%, checked again in a month |
| Watch | Between break-even and target | Fix lead quality, booking or follow-up first; budget flat |
| Cut | Below break-even for two months with enough data | Budget moves to a campaign that scales |
A worked example
A fictional HVAC company runs three campaigns in the shoulder season:
| Campaign | Spend | Closed revenue | Return | Margin | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HVAC replacement | $4,000 | $28,000 | 7.0× | 40% | Scale |
| Emergency AC repair | $3,000 | $15,000 | 5.0× | 55% | Keep |
| Seasonal tune-ups | $2,500 | $6,000 | 2.4× | 55% | Watch |
Replacements are well over target and the crew has room, so the budget goes up in a step. Repair is healthy, so it stays. Tune-ups are above break-even but under target, so before touching the budget we look at what the tune-up customers spend over a year.
Before you cut
A campaign that took months to learn can lose that learning in a day. Ad platforms need history to bid well, and switching a campaign off and on again resets a lot of it. So before cutting, look at what sits behind the number:
- Are the leads bookable, or is targeting bringing the wrong jobs?
- Are they answered fast?
- Are estimates followed up?
- Is the landing page right for the job?
Fix those first and give it a full month or two. Only cut when the campaign stays below break-even with enough data to be sure.
The lifetime exception
Maintenance and membership campaigns often lose money on the first visit and win later on memberships, repairs and replacements. Judge them on what a customer spends over 12 months, not on the first ticket.
Use the right revenue
All of this runs on closed revenue from your CRM, with a 30 to 60 day window for jobs that take time to close. Not on the conversions an ad platform reports, and not on cost per lead.
Check capacity before you scale
A campaign can beat its target and still be the wrong one to scale if the crew is booked out. Extra leads in a full schedule mostly wait, cancel or go to a competitor. Scale into the months where you have room, and shift budget toward higher-value work when you don’t.
Make it a monthly ritual
Once a month, put every campaign on one page with its spend, revenue, return and decision. It takes twenty minutes, and it’s the difference between marketing that drifts and marketing you steer.
See it on your own numbers
The free revenue leak check compares your numbers with shops in your trade, prices your biggest leak and shows how far your current leads can take you toward your revenue goal. It takes 30 seconds.
Check your leaks